Overall Rating -> 10

Filters need to be improved but rest of website is great

Posted By Rock hound in December, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

GemSelect offers excellent choices, prices & service- highly recommended! Unfortunately, prior to ordering a replacement gemstone, my jeweler neglected to mention it needed to be one that was a'cushion cuta' to fit the existing mount. Have yet to return/exchangea'

Posted By CJ in March, 2026

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 8

Site worked well and helped me find a rock that matched what I was looking for. Well within budget and I trust it will show up, so that's definitely positive. Not much else to it. Satisfied.

Posted By Big Ricky in May, 2026

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

A pleasant experience and many choices to choose from

Posted By Krackenking in November, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

No problems. I had a minor address issue in the past and someone got back to me very quickly and we resolved the issue satisfactorily. I appreciated the quick, concerned response. So important when buyer/seller are so far apart in distance. Thank you Gem Select. Keep up the good work!

Posted By Orphanboy in December, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

I have a beautiful emerald I purchased from a company names gemselect and they are awesome! You should try them out?

Posted By Lynn in September, 2025

Source: Bizrate