GemSelect Certified Store Reviews
GemSelect: Over 22 Years in the Gemstone Business! Thank you for trusting us with your purchase!
Overall Rating -> 10 
I always enjoy the selection and the unique cuts I can find here. I would love to see more hex cuts tho! Maybe some rose cuts too!
Posted By Blkfower83 in October, 2024
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
went well
Posted By Doug in May, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
I've made several purchases through GemSelect in the past, although not within the last six months. Their gems are always beautiful and I have never had an issue with their prices or their stones. Even when I'm not buying, I love scrolling through their website, which is very user friendly. I especially appreciate being able to change the listing order to your own liking, such as most to least expensive, largest to smallest, etc. As with most online orders, however, I think the shipping charges are not commensurate with the actual weight of the items shipped.
Posted By DrLHS in November, 2024
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
When I need a specific stone, gem select is my go to shop. Always a good experience and a great product.
Posted By LeAnn in April, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
I trust this company to deliver exactly what is offered. I have never had to return a selection of Gems. I appreciate the company's detailed description of their product. It helps this customer find mounts before the gems arrive. Any day of the year one can find a wide selection of gems, be it by price, color, cut, lot or single. Pricing does not jump all over the place and stays reasonable. Be assured your items will arrive in perfect condition as the company's shipping department does a great job.
Posted By Miss Sherrie in August, 2024
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 8 
The website was nice and I bought some gems
Posted By Jay in December, 2024
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 9 
I wish there were options for jewelry settings
Posted By Tim in May, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
I really liked the email, and the link that help return me to the site. I didnt have access to my card info while checking out and I had to put my phone away so I lost the tab. Fortunately, since I did give an email- they sent me a link that brought me back to where I was. Greatly appreciated
Posted By Jag in January, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
I was looking for a site with every type of gem I could want for setting in luxury blades and assumed I would need to look outside the US, but GemSelect made it easy to get everything I wanted without leaving the house! Wide enough selection that I do not feel the need to look elsewhere and pricing the same.
Posted By Razormane in April, 2025
Source: Bizrate