GemSelect Certified Store Reviews
GemSelect: Over 22 Years in the Gemstone Business! Thank you for trusting us with your purchase!
Overall Rating -> 10 
This was my first experience with this company. I had no difficulty finding the item I wanted, and checking out was a breeze! Ia'm hoping my item arrives quickly, intact, and of good quality. Overall, this was a very satisfactory experience.
Posted By Gem connoisseur in August, 2026
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 7 
Overall the site is good to use and simple to navigate for what i needed and i liked that they are clear and detailed on the size shape and cut of the stones only input id like is for stones that have a specific refractive quality like moonstone in my case if theyd showcase the cut stones refraction so you know how it looks when buying
Posted By Revenant in August, 2026
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 7 
Could not get it to work 25 times.
Posted By Dock in July, 2026
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
Very good.
Posted By Tommy in December, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 8 
Site worked well and helped me find a rock that matched what I was looking for. Well within budget and I trust it will show up, so that's definitely positive. Not much else to it. Satisfied.
Posted By Big Ricky in May, 2026
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
I needed a very specific color of tourmaline and Gem Select had it. I had to get the client to agree and then ordered the stone. It arrived better than pictured and we all were very happy.
Posted By Tim W in February, 2026
Source: Bizrate