GemSelect Certified Store Reviews
GemSelect: Over 22 Years in the Gemstone Business! Thank you for trusting us with your purchase!
Overall Rating -> 10 
The website design looks dated and not particularly up to date with what you would expect from a site selling gemstones - however the product information is clearly laid out and well marked, with details for each product sold.
Posted By Online Shopper in December, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
My experience has always been fantastic. Today I saved 6 gems to email a customer looking for a particular color blend to fit into an east west setting, so her options were limited, but we found one she wanted, deleted all the others in the cart and order the gem she selected. It was helpful to be able to put them in the cart so I could save them until she selected the one she wanted without having to research all of them again.
Posted By RJ in January, 2026
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
The website was very easy to use.
Posted By Garnet in January, 2026
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 8 
It was a good interaction I got a good gemstone for cheap
Posted By Jon in December, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 9 
I was looking for a small gift for a friend- the process is the same as every other time and was very simple, and she even got her gift early! On the downside, there's no way to easily keep track of multiple Shipping Addresses, so if I want to send a gift to Friend A and to Friend B, I have to overwrite everything and it's a fair bit clunky in that regard.
Posted By Jezzi in June, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
Absolutely love the website, selection and products. Can you guys add a gemstones with inclusions tab. I like those it'd be nice to have them all in one place but i do understand it would be alot of work to go through and categorize them. Thank you anyways
Posted By The homie edgar in December, 2025
Source: Bizrate