GemSelect Certified Store Reviews
GemSelect: Over 22 Years in the Gemstone Business! Thank you for trusting us with your purchase!
Overall Rating -> 10 
GemSelect offers excellent choices, prices & service- highly recommended! Unfortunately, prior to ordering a replacement gemstone, my jeweler neglected to mention it needed to be one that was a'cushion cuta' to fit the existing mount. Have yet to return/exchangea'
Posted By CJ in March, 2026
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 8 
I've purchased things from GemSelect before. What you see is what you get, which is not always the case with gem sites online. You can find some good value with gem select, and I will buy from them again.
Posted By Meyeusername in March, 2026
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10
I feel Gemselect is a trustworthy company to buy from
Posted By Becky in October, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 9 
I did not realize these stones were of jewelry quality. They are really beautiful, just not what I was expecting which was more of a natural stone.
Posted By Jewelry Quality Stones in July, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10
On the clarity options it goes "and better" so if youre looking for si specifically and you click si and better it still shows you basically everything. It just removes the opaques. Itd be nice if it was vs only, vss only, si only, etc
Posted By Iamnotakrustykrab in December, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 9
the gems were smaller than I thought but I was at fault for not reading the complete discrimination
Posted By Tim in May, 2025
Source: Bizrate
