GemSelect Certified Store Reviews
GemSelect: Over 22 Years in the Gemstone Business! Thank you for trusting us with your purchase!
Overall Rating -> 10 
I liked the selection of gems, and price.
I did not like your PayPal process. I already have a PP account and you want me to sign up for another.
Posted By CLTCJH in May, 2026
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
I needed a very specific color of tourmaline and Gem Select had it. I had to get the client to agree and then ordered the stone. It arrived better than pictured and we all were very happy.
Posted By Tim W in February, 2026
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
No problems. I had a minor address issue in the past and someone got back to me very quickly and we resolved the issue satisfactorily. I appreciated the quick, concerned response. So important when buyer/seller are so far apart in distance. Thank you Gem Select. Keep up the good work!
Posted By Orphanboy in December, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
The stones are very nice.
Posted By Mvk in August, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
Easy picking, fast checkout, secure shipping. Cana't ask for anything more than efficiency and a good price.
Posted By Beman in September, 2025
Source: Bizrate
Overall Rating -> 10 
They have a wonderful selection of gems of all sorts, shapes, cuts, and quality. I am very particular about the quality of stones I buy, and found many with VVS clarity and excellent cut and polish. I am thrilled with each of the stones I purchased, and would definitely recommend GemSelect to everyone.
Posted By Debsarabs in February, 2026
Source: Bizrate