Natural Loose Gemstones for Jewelry & Collecting

Overall Rating -> 10

The citrine gems are beautiful. I appreciated that each stone was individually shown on the website so I could see exactly what I was getting. No mystery person selecting random stones for me. The documentation included with each gem was high quality as well. Great price and arrived as expected.

Posted By Jen in December, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

They have a wonderful selection of gems of all sorts, shapes, cuts, and quality. I am very particular about the quality of stones I buy, and found many with VVS clarity and excellent cut and polish. I am thrilled with each of the stones I purchased, and would definitely recommend GemSelect to everyone.

Posted By Debsarabs in February, 2026

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

I was looking for high-quality amethyst on this site, and I was able to compare size, color, and weight in detail before making a purchase.

Posted By Atsuhisa in January, 2026

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

I needed a very specific color of tourmaline and Gem Select had it. I had to get the client to agree and then ordered the stone. It arrived better than pictured and we all were very happy.

Posted By Tim W in February, 2026

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 9

The purchasing process is fairly quick and straightforward and for me user friendly so it probably took more or less than 3 minutes to purchase and pay for the items. I wish there was a discount offer for multiple items to encourage us buyers to purchase more an incentive and add more sales in your end. Besides that, it's been a great purchasing experience and will continue to shop as I am a repeat customer and have bought from your store many times before. Thank you.

Posted By Emmanuel in October, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

All items were delivered on time with all items meeting or exceeding my expectations. Cut, clarity and color were very close to the photos and description.

Posted By Bob D in December, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 9

Very good and simple exchange

Posted By Waylon in March, 2026

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

GemSelect offers excellent choices, prices & service- highly recommended! Unfortunately, prior to ordering a replacement gemstone, my jeweler neglected to mention it needed to be one that was a'cushion cuta' to fit the existing mount. Have yet to return/exchangea'

Posted By CJ in March, 2026

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

The website was very easy to use.

Posted By Garnet in January, 2026

Source: Bizrate