Selling Quality Loose Gemstones at Fair Prices

Overall Rating -> 10

I am filling a small treasure chest and picked a nice amethyst.

Posted By VinnyD in August, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

I have shopped at Gemselect for nearly 20 years. I especially like that you see pictures of the exact gem you are purchasing. You are a trusted source.

Posted By DNaber in October, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

On the clarity options it goes "and better" so if youre looking for si specifically and you click si and better it still shows you basically everything. It just removes the opaques. Itd be nice if it was vs only, vss only, si only, etc

Posted By Iamnotakrustykrab in December, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 9

The website was easy to use and informative of the selection of stones it has. I quickly found the right stone for me.

Posted By Guero in March, 2026

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

went well

Posted By Doug in May, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

Very neat and to the point

Posted By Botha in March, 2026

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 9

I was looking for a small gift for a friend- the process is the same as every other time and was very simple, and she even got her gift early! On the downside, there's no way to easily keep track of multiple Shipping Addresses, so if I want to send a gift to Friend A and to Friend B, I have to overwrite everything and it's a fair bit clunky in that regard.

Posted By Jezzi in June, 2025

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

I was looking for high-quality amethyst on this site, and I was able to compare size, color, and weight in detail before making a purchase.

Posted By Atsuhisa in January, 2026

Source: Bizrate

Overall Rating -> 10

Had a great experience and the prices are great

Posted By BuBx99 in November, 2025

Source: Bizrate