Garnet is mostly known for its red varieties, and its green varieties are also highly sought-after, particulary Tsavorite garnet and rare demantoid garnet. Orange garnet gemstones are an interesting choice when it comes to choosing an orange gem for you jewelry. Many of the red garnet often occur with slight traces of spessartite which will cause them to be slightly orangey. In additional to Fanta-orange spessartite garnet, have a look at almandine garnet, hessonite garnet, malaya or malaia garnet, mali garnet and even color-change garnet.
It's pretty great having a whole lot of different gemstones to choose from. When doing crafts and jewelry making, it's great to have all kinds of options, and it's amazing how much cheaper it is to just purchase un-set gemstones and make the setting yourself, as opposed to buying fully-made jewelry already. It's also extra special since you made it yourself.