Over 19 Years in the Gemstone Business!
Thank you for trusting us with your purchase!
Overall Rating -> 9 
over the experience was similar to other sites i have used. The only real note I have is the checkout experience was tedious and discriminatory, i wouldn't accept visa gift cards, which not only have guaranteed funds but help protect from misuse of personal information, but would not accept my visa b/c it is a prepaid card. I don't have bank account and I have been using the prepaid card for years without issue so this was disappointing to me. I feel safer using reputable gem sites rather than amazon or ebay (I have been sold fake gems with fake certs on both), but not being able to use my own valid legitimate funds and having to find a friend to buy for me b/c I use a non-bank card like 40% of the country is insulting.
Posted By Iggywiggly in January, 2024
Overall Rating -> 9
I have been buy from you for years
Posted By JohnA in May, 2023
Overall Rating -> 10 
Fantastic dealer for quality gemstones. Website is easy to navigate, selection is superb, delivery of purchases is prompt. Easy to select incorrect payment options, however.
Posted By David W in May, 2023
Overall Rating -> 10
I love your selection of gems. My only complaing is I wish I could put in a page number to return to that page.When there are over 60 pages of gems it is hard to return to a page with a gem I am considering.
Posted By Cahall in March, 2024
Overall Rating -> 10
Very detailed and great pictures
Posted By Alexandrite in November, 2023
Overall Rating -> 10
No issues at all. It was great.
Posted By LJXK in May, 2023
Overall Rating -> 9
So many gorgeous stones! The only "complaint" I have is it's difficult to visualize sizes in mm. Perhaps some way to compare in inches?It has been a long time since I bought stones from Gem select, but the process wasn't too difficult.
Posted By Ktreva52 in February, 2024
Overall Rating -> 9
I was in the market for birthstones for a lil gift project im doing. I'm no expert in gems or what not but the quality as far as i can tell seems to be spot on.
Posted By PixelComposer in January, 2024
Overall Rating -> 10
i love this site, the gems are always of good quality, i've been buy gifts from the site for 10 years, love it
Posted By Jf in January, 2024
Overall Rating -> 10
Gem Select has gems at afffordable prices.
Posted By George in March, 2024
Overall Rating -> 7 
I placed order#384714 based on the picture on your website and the stone came in much darker. I'm sure it's the same stone i ordered but your lighting made it seem a lighter blue. I was trying to match a stone for a customer and based on the picture it would have been close enough but the stone in person is a mile off.
Posted By Bobk in February, 2024
Overall Rating -> 10
After having looked at other purchasing sites, this is my first choice.
Posted By MJC in January, 2024
Overall Rating -> 7
I feel pretty good so far, pending the delivery of the item ordered.
Posted By Steve in November, 2023
Overall Rating -> 10
The website is very easy to use. The search function, filter and sort functions are very helpful.
Posted By Sboro in August, 2023
Overall Rating -> 9
The selection and filtering is a little overwhelming, but that's only because there is so much to choose from.
Posted By Kasper in June, 2023
